The world of crime fiction has a thousand nuances and a thousand styles. The American novel of all life is not the same as its British cousin, nor the dark intrigues of northern Europe as the bright life of Italians. In this post I want to focus on the two subgenres that I frequent the most:
- Nordic crime novel, what we call scandinoir .
- Italian police, the well-known gialli (literally, yellow).
And I have a theory: both branches are very marked by the environment, both social and purely meteorological. I will base my explanation on the series I know.
The North: Scandinavian
The Scandinavian family is as dark as a winter night in Oslo, and the crimes tend to be bloodier and the motives more convoluted. The best example is Jo Nesbø's detective Harry Hole: a sad, tortured, alcoholic disaster who, nevertheless, knows how to be funny. Here are some examples of the books I liked the most by this author:
- The Robin : It left me disoriented until the end.
- Knife : a good deal of suffering (what a bad slob, this man).
- Eclipse : It starts with Harry lying in a bar in California and leaves me with a slap in the face.
- The Heir : the first of Nesbø's books without Harry that I liked.
- Minnesota : a book that doesn't take place in Scandinavia and yet I liked it. Will this be the beginning of another series?
Next to him I put Sebastian Bergman, the Stockholm psychologist with zero empathy and a lot of son of a bitch who I follow, more than anything, to know which one will be the big one. Here the cast is more choral (Torkel, Ursula, Vanja, Billy...), but it doesn't delve too much into the personal lives of the patrol. I started the series with Imperfect Secrets , an almost perfect noir, while Expendable Deaths seemed more like an impasse , with a Sebastian who was too reformed.
I close the north with brief mentions of authors I haven't read that much:
- Erika Falck, by Camilla Läckberg: more everyday, but with a "politically correct" tone that I don't expect in this type of book. It's the one that inspires me the least.
- Arnaldur Indriðason and his Erlendur Sveinsson, from the Reykjavík police: I read Jar City ( Las marismas ) with zero expectations and I loved it. I guessed the murderer early, yes, but the reading is stimulating and everything is well connected, with Erlendur's personal dramas in the middle of the Icelandic cold.
- Ragnar Jónasson: I've only tasted it, but it leaves that anxiety that won't let you get out of your chair. North of the North, in its purest form.
The South: gialli
Why do they call books of this genre gialli (yellow) in Italy? Well, because of the color of the covers: in 1929 the publishing house Mondadori released a collection of detective novels with yellow covers ("I Libri Gialli"), and yellow ended up christening the entire genre. The name already suggests that they are something else: the background is much brighter, the crimes are not usually so macabre and, above all, there is a lot of environment (friends, family and, most importantly, food).
The first major character is Salvo Montalbano , by Camilleri, who spends half his life praising the smell of things and fucking like a slob in an imaginary town in Sicily, by the sea. The town is called Vigata, and it is so well drawn that you feel at home there. He is, by far, the dean of Italian investigators, with a series of more than 25 books (not including the spin-offs ), which I have read in order.
Around him there is a gang that makes you love him: my favorite is Fazio, the one who brings order, and don't miss Catarella, all naivety, capable of getting emotional with an orphan cat.
Among all the cases/books, I highlight these two:
- A Decisive Turn ( Il giro di boa ): a very tough investigation into child trafficking in which, incidentally, Montalbano realizes that he is getting older (and I really like the idea of characters getting older).
- The Dance of the Seagull ( La danza del gabbiano ): the one that struck me the most in the entire series. Here Camilleri dares to make Fazio disappear, and the whole team has to pull together to find him and, at the same time, solve the case behind it. A considerable high.
From the same school, but much more fringe, comes Rocco Schiavone, "son" of Antonio Manzini: a Roman policeman exiled to Aosta who hates the cold, says tacos like no one else and starts the day with a club in the office. He is one of the most unempathetic and at the same time tender characters in gialli and, with Camilleri out of action, I would say that Manzini has become the new king of the Italian detective novel.
He doesn't work alone: there's his squad from the police station and, above all, Lupa, the inseparable dog who steals many of his scenes. Like Camilleri, his books are published by Sellerio and, although I recommend them all, I highlight this couple:
- Adam's Rib (La costola di Adamo) : Rocco investigates a supposed suicide (is it, or isn't it?), and along the way we see his friendship with Pierron deepen. I got over it in less than 48 hours.
- ELP (Italian only): Manzini celebrates the character's 10th anniversary, with Rocco and his crew in top form. Plus, there's a slightly eccentric character who makes it really, really funny.
I close the Italians with three brief mentions:
- Ernesto Maccadò, by Andrea Vitali: the only married man in the group, set in the mid-20th century near Lake Garda, with a beautiful historical reenactment and cases that don't always involve death. A cantare fu il cane and Olive comprese are good entry points.
- Imma Tatarani, by Mariolina Venezia: Imma is a substitute prosecutor in Matera (Basilicata), short, with a peculiar sense of fashion and always in stiletto heels. She can be cute or the opposite, depending on the moment. I loved the first one in the series: Come piante tra sassi .
- Cristina Cassar Scalia: has two characters in two separate series, both set in Sicily. On the one hand, Vanina Guarrasi, a young and very current vice-questor in Catania (she already has three or four books, translated into Spanish); on the other, Scipione Macchiavelli, male protagonist of a historical series set in Sicily in the sixties. Maybe she is following in Camilleri's footsteps?
Where to start
My advice, as always, is to start with the first volume of each series and work your way up. But if you want a shortcut, here's mine:
- Tortured North: The Robin (Harry Hole).
- North Choral: Imperfect Secrets (Sebastian Bergman).
- Frozen North: Jar City (Erlendur Sveinsson).
- Bright South: The Voice of the Violin (Salvo Montalbano).
- South with bad drool: La costola di Adamo (Rocco Schiavone).
In short, within the same label ("novel noir"), night and day fit together. What color do you want yours to be? Yellow or black? Have you read any books by these characters?








